I have now written a brief piece on possible ways to mitigate the risk of sequence of returns.
Some of the approaches are not intuitive!
Sequence (of returns) risk is something I mentioned in my recent piece about my upcoming third quarter portfolio review. Sequence risk is a major factor in my planning as our household heads into retirement in the near future.
Looking at the current valuation of the S&P 500 vs. underlying gross national product is a bit sobering.
September brings my next quarterly portfolio review and my next, self-imposed, securities trading window (I only trade four times a year). I have been giving a fair bit of thought this summer to what’s next for our portfolio.
Canadian MoneySaver published my latest article on thematic investing in the July/August 2018 edition.
This time I discuss the investment opportunities in alternative energy. While there are headwinds in the short to medium term, long term this theme offers considerable potential, especially in Asian markets.
See more here (paywall): Canadian MoneySaver
The Ottawa Share Club fantasy growth and income portfolio reports as of June 30, 2018 are now posted.
The fantasy growth portfolio has been doing very well year-to-date and overall:
- Up 7.3% year-to-date
- Up 38.0% since inception (January 1, 2016)
The fantasy income portfolio is in positive territory this year (and overall) but has lagged the growth portfolio (as one might expect):
- Up 1.1% year-to-date
- Up 16.7% since inception (January 1, 2016)
With the second quarter completed, I’ve updated my secular trends fantasy portfolio performance report.
It’s been a strong year so far for the overall performance, but some themes are doing much better than others.
The total portfolio has delivered a 5.89% total return so far this year. The leaders are Amplify Online Retail ETF (IBUY), up ~25% and ETFMG Prime Cyber Security ETF (HACK), up ~17%.
The laggards are Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (VWO), down ~7% and iShares Global Clean Energy ETF (ICLN), down ~5%.
By contrast, my secular trends benchmark is up only ~1% year to date. Other major indexes have total returns year to date as follows:
- NASDAQ (QQQ) +10.6%
- S&P 500 (SPY) +2.52%
- TSX Composite (XIC) +1.14%
- Dow Jones Industrial Average (DIA) -0.91
So, secular investing this year so far has done fairly well even though performance varies widely by theme. See the full performance report here.
I’ve published my second quarter of 2018 portfolio review. In it I discuss my current take on managing our household portfolio, some of the trades I’ve recently made and my thoughts for the rest of the year.
See my review here.
The material from the June 12, 2018 Ottawa Share Club meeting has been published. It includes:
- Peter’s slides presented by Brad and Eric on the use of advisors through the investment lifecycle.
- Peter’s appendix about the difference between a dealing representative and an advising representative.
- Margot Pomerleau’s slides on how to work with a financial advisor.
- A pamphlet from Margot Pomerleau’s firm on the complaints process for retail investors in Canada (bonus material).
See all the content here.
I have a confession to make. I have broken my own asset allocation rules with my second quarter trades.
I bought more equities even though I was already a bit overweight in them.
Why did I do this?
My reasoning is as follows:
- I have a relatively low target equity weight to begin with (46% of our portfolio)
- I had a lot of cash on hand (way over 10% of our portfolio)
- I have more cash becoming available due to savings, bond maturities, dividends and interest in the next 12 months or less
- quite a bit of that cash was in our TFSAs and I wanted to get that money working at better than than bond returns since the returns are tax free
- bond yields are still not that attractive in spite of rising rates (~3.1% yield-to-maturity on a five-year investment grade corporate bond)
- there are a lot of relatively good deals in consumer staples, utilities and telecommunications right now – several companies are off their highs and are trading at reasonable multiples
- these three sectors are pretty defensive and could do OK in a recessionary environment
- I only bought high quality equities with relatively low risk and often decent dividends (with one or two exceptions)
- I did not add any new positions, just added to our existing holdings to increase their position size to something more in line with our average position size
- Next quarter is another opportunity to review our portfolio and decide if we should trim some of the big gainers, especially in technology, which are starting to become more dominant single positions in our holdings
What I bought (all in our TFSAs):
- Algonquin Power (AQN) – initially bought in my Canadian TFSA and journalled to my US TFSA to get the dividend that is paid in US dollars without conversion back to Canadian dollars
- Bell Canada Enterprises (BCE)
- Fortis (FTS)
- Loblaw (L) – has a relatively low dividend
- ONEX (ONEX) – this is an exception as it is a growth stock with a very small dividend in the multi-sector holdings industry
- North West Co (NWC)
- Telus (T)
I also bought some bonds:
- CALLOWAY-I 3.985% 30MY23
- FAIRFAX FINL 4.5% 22MR23
- CANADIAN WESTERN BANK Maturity Jun 16 2022 Coupon 2.737
So, after this investment “spree,” our weightings vs. targets are as follows:
|Total Cash/Near Cash||9.0%||9.4%||0.4%|
All in all, we’re still in a pretty conservative posture and continue to have flexibility with cash levels if needed.
More to come in early July when I publish my Q2 portfolio review.
Brad updated Steven Brown’s Retirement Forecaster Excel spreadsheet tool (version 2.7.2). The changes are as follows:
Version 2.7.2 provides support for defined benefit (DB) pension plans with a Bridge Benefit (such as the Fed Government or Ontario Teachers) and the accompanying DB Survivor pension. Detailed input instructions are provided on the Instructions sheet, under the Instructions section.
You may access the material on Brad’s page here.
I’ve launched a new fantasy portfolio on the money4retirement.ca website to track secular, or thematic trends for investors.
A secular trend is:
An investment trend associated with some characteristic or phenomenon that is not cyclical or seasonal but exists over a relatively long period.
The rationale for doing this and the initial portfolio structure is presented here.
The first secular trends fantasy portfolio tracking report (and its benchmark) is presented here.
I’ve also added a new menu option called “Secular trends and investing” on the site for quick access.
WalMart, the once-stodgy bricks and mortar retailer, made news today with its largest acquisition ever – $15B US for 75% of eCommerce retailer Flipkart in India.
It reportedly beat out Amazon for the deal.
WalMart shares dropped 3% on the news.
Amazon’s shares rose 1%.
Softbank appears to have done very well. Other players were involved including Alphabet, Microsoft, Tencent Holdings and Naspers.
The deal hasn’t fully closed yet….
More from Bloomberg here.
See Brad and Peter’s deck on financial independence / retire early (FIRE) presented at the May 8, 2018 Ottawa Share Club meeting is available here.
The decks from Mark Seed on DRIPping and from myself (Michael Patenaude) on the Q1 2018 OSC fantasy portfolios and sector allocations presented at the April 17, 2018 Ottawa Share Club meeting are posted here.
“In its newly released April 2018 Fiscal Monitor, the International Monetary Fund projected that the United States is the only — yes, only — advanced economy in the world expected to have its debt burden get worse over the next five years.” – Washington Post
Tax cuts, and the possibility of more or extended tax cuts. Who’s going to pay the government’s demographically-driven growing bills?
What’s next, cut entitlements? That doesn’t sound recessionary to me (/s for sarcasm!).
By contrast, Canada is doing pretty well with its debt management. Ignore the noise, focus on the facts. Glad to be north of the border.
I’ve completed my first quarter portfolio review.
Quite a difference from last year so far. Our household portfolio is flat so far this year. That’s a bit better than some of the major indexes, but not all.
I have a link in my review to some evidence that markets in the US might be soft until the mid-terms, and then could rebound a lot. So hopefully things will improve as the year progresses.
Find out more here.
It’s been over a year since I last wrote about macro risks emanating from the US and how they might affect Canadian investors.
Given how many changes are taking place in the macro environment recently, and how influential the US macro situation is for Canadians, I thought it would be interesting to do an update. The idea is to try to identify major driving factors that might affect US, Canadian and global equity markets in an effort to reduce the “surprise factor,” which may in turn lead to bad investment decisions (out of fear or panic).
So what does the macro risk profile look like south of the border? No one really knows for sure of course, but it is interesting to contemplate, especially if you have any US holdings in your portfolio.
Let’s take a look at some of the frequently-cited risks that may affect investors and try to determine if relative risk levels have increased or decreased since my last effort at this in January 2017.
I have listed them from what I propose are the highest to the lowest risks.
⇑ = risk is increasing
⇔ = risk is not changing
⇓ = risk is decreasing
Tax Risk = ⇑ (increased risk rating since Jan/17)
• Definition: the risk that an investment will lose its value or return on capital because of taxation (most investments are subject to this risk)
• My take: Recently, Trump decided to impose new taxes, in the form of tariffs, on steel and aluminum, and on various goods manufactured in China. China is already beginning to retaliate, raising the prospect of a trade war. It is unclear if Trump will lay on even more tariffs. It remains to be seen what the economic impact of new tariffs will be but the general consensus appears to be net negative due to rising costs of goods for consumers. Corporate and limited personal income tax cuts were delivered in December 2017 so that matter is settled for now.
Political Risk = ⇑ (same risk rating as Jan/17, but the overall risk is likely higher)
• Definition: the risk that an investment will lose value because of political action in a country where one has investments, including one’s own country
• My take: While his core support seems to be holding, the US president remains erratic and sensational in policy pronouncements, his cabinet turnover is record-setting, new cabinet and legal advisory appointments are arguably increasingly controversial and recently look like they are veering hard to the right of political spectrum and more confrontational in tone. Relations with Iran may become increasingly strained while relations with North Korea could possibly (but not likely) improve (the new national security advisor, John Bolton, advocates war with both countries). The president continues to accommodate, even congratulate Russia while many observers suggest this is inappropriate given demonstrable evidence of Russian interference in the last US election among several other concerns. The Mueller investigation continues to slowly gain momentum on three fronts: Trump’s possible (likely?) obstruction of justice; Trump/team conspiracy with Russia to tip the last election; and Trump/family financial dealings, including potential money laundering. New revelations about Cambridge Analytica’s role in the 2016 election and potential connections to Russian interference are gaining a bit more traction. The trial for Paul Manafort, Trump’s former campaign chairman, begins in July and further indictments by Mueller in other cases remain likely. The ongoing investigation means a constitutional crisis could easily be triggered if Trump does indeed fire the Special Council as he reportedly intended to do last summer, and may be more inclined than ever to do given his recent appointment of Joseph diGenova, who claims the domestic security establishment (a.k.a. “deep state”) in the US is trying to frame Trump. The possibility of impeachment is likely remote still, but increasing. There are mid-term elections in November which could lead to one or both Houses of Congress flipping to the Democrats, thus hobbling Trump’s agenda and making him accountable. Given all this uncertainty, I believe political risk is elevating in the US and by extension the world.
Market Risk = ⇑ (same risk rating as Jan/17, but the overall risk is likely higher)
• Definition: the risk that an investment can lose its value in the market (applies to equities and fixed-income investments)
• My take: Given the US market had been climbing steadily since November 8, 2016, the recent pullbacks have been long overdue. Most market gyrations tend to be short-term in nature and are of little consequence to long-term investors. Many commentators still claim the market is over-valued based on historical price/earnings ratios. Overall though the backdrop of corporate earnings, economic growth and planned orderly increases in interest rates contribute to medium term optimism in equity markets. There are no compelling hints of a recession yet on the horizon. Having said that, volatility has been increasing so far in 2018 (the ^VIX is up 125%), in large part due to increasing political, inflation and tax uncertainties. Market risk is being reflected CNN’s Fear and Greed Index (7% out of 100%) and in the recent drops in major indexes. Of the three major US indexes, only the NASDAQ is in the black so far this year. I would suggest market risk is rising due to heightened uncertainty in the political and tax environments discussed in this post and the recent increase in volatility.
Legislative Risk = ⇔ (reduced risk rating since Jan/17)
• Definition: the risk that an investment will lose value or benefits because of new legislation (all investments are subject to this risk)
• My take: This risk is related to political risk. The most recent spending law (as of writing today still unpassed before a midnight deadline) appears to be ignoring fiscal conservatism. Regulations related to offshore drilling, the environment and banking have been changed and, again, in the short to medium term are being well-received by investors. Longer term, these changes could be damaging to the US economy by contributing significantly to increased US fiscal indebtedness, reckless banking practices, over-stimulation of the economy, environmental degradations and potential knock-on inflationary impacts. NAFTA talks drag on, with some signs the US may be softening its position, especially in the auto sector. If a new deal is not struck soon, there will be little time for Congressional ratification, leaving the future uncertain. We don’t know what else could be forthcoming in the legislative and regulatory environment, but presumably not too much will change before at least the fall mid-term elections. If in fact a Democratic House of Representatives emerges, this would likely provide a damper on Trump’s legislative agenda.
Interest Rate Risk = ⇔ (reduced risk rating since Jan/17)
• Definition: the risk that an investment will lose value due to a change in interest rates (applies to fixed-income investments and sometimes to equity investments depending on investor expectations for interest rate changes)
• My take: Interest rates are still on track to rise three times this year (once already this week) even with the appointment of a new Fed Chairman. With two more rate increases promised in 2018, on top of this week’s rate increase, the market should be prepared. Wage inflation, in large part due to low unemployment coupled with economic growth, could also be a driver of higher than expected interest rates later this year, which could be bad for equity markets. We saw the market react to some of these expectations earlier in the year. Due to the combined effects of tax cuts and increased deficit spending expected this year, the US federal debt will climb, which is not positive for rates longer term. This is a tough one to forecast at the best of times but on balance it would seem interest rate risk in the short to medium term has decreased since January 2017.
Purchasing Power Risk = ⇔ (reduced risk rating since Jan/17)
• Definition: the risk that an investment will lose its purchasing power due to inflation (applies particularly to cash and fixed-income investments)
• My take: This risk is somewhat related to interest rate and tax risks in that the main concern would be higher-than-expected inflation, driven by wages, higher health care costs and possibly new tariffs, but counterbalanced to some degree by lower personal and corporate taxes. If Trump’s policies end up being inflationary then purchasing power may erode. This would likely take some time to happen. On balance the risk of higher inflation, from a very low level since the 2008/09 financial crisis, has probably increased, but for the short to medium term does not appear very likely to happen. The recent tax cuts, especially to individuals, will marginally add to purchasing power in the short to medium term and low unemployment could eventually cause wages to go up, improving purchasing strength of individuals.
Liquidity Risk = ⇔ (same risk rating as Jan/17)
• Definition: the risk that an investment will not be easy to sell when needed (applies to some equities that don’t trade in large volume, fixed-income investments and real estate and other property that may be hard to sell quickly at an equitable price)
• My take: I don’t see any reason to think liquidity risk has changed since January 2017– at least not in the short term. If some of the other risks in this post materialize, this could change, and possibly quickly. I leave this risk at the mercy of “black swans” without changing the risk rating from January 2017.
Reinvestment Risk = ⇓ (same risk rating as Jan/17)
• Definition: the risk that an investment will be reinvested at a lower rate of interest when it matures (applies to fixed-income investments)
• My take: If we expect interest rates to continue an orderly climb higher in 2018, new money that is being invested in fixed income should attract higher rates. If one deploys fixed income funds to rate reset preferred shares and/or bond funds or bond/GIC ladders of short to medium term duration (e.g. five years or less) then reinvestment risk should be falling.
Are there any actionable ideas here?
I believe that several risks I am tracking are falling, but the three risks that I believe are increasing (political, taxation and market) could have major impacts in the short to medium term. Longer term I remain somewhat optimistic.
With rates rising south and north of the border, and related sector rotation, there has been pressure on utilities, telecoms, consumer staples, materials and energy this year. Bond prices are slightly weaker so far this year as rates rise. I recently added to both utilities and bonds.
If the technology sector continues to outpace this year, I will at some point likely need to re-balance to reduce the percentage this sector represents in our portfolio. It is roughly 20% now and rising.
As stated over a year ago when last reviewing macro risks, I continue to balance short-term risk with longer term secular trends. Since January 2017 I have bought an ETF for robotics. I continue to hold biotechnology and water-themed ETFs and I continue to hold Shopify in the e-Commerce space (although I trimmed it somewhat last year). I am researching both alternative energy and cybersecurity as other possible investment themes for new cash in the future (and likely will be writing articles on them for Canadian MoneySaver).
In conclusion, it remains pretty much stay the course for me. I have an expectation that things will be more volatile in equity markets in 2018 compared to 2017. So I remain prepared for that eventuality. Otherwise, who knows?
Just a quick post to point out that for the third time so far this year, CNN’s fear and greed index is down below 10 (on a scale of 0 to 100). This suggests, by its seven measures, investors are “extremely fearful” of the US equity markets right now.
Hmmm. What’s on sale in the markets? (Hint: telecoms, consumer staples, energy, utilities and materials).
The trades from the March 13, 2018 OSC Meeting (sell ATD.B and buy WEED) have been posted in the change log.
See the material from last Tuesday night’s meeting featuring:
- Callum Sutherland, Financial Security Advisor, Freedom 55 Financial deck on Behavioural Finance and RRIF plus Annuity Strategy
- Dave and Eric’s presentation on Market Corrections
- Notes taken by Andre about PJ’s suggested trade in the OSC
See the content here.
I had some unexpected time available today to make my first quarter trades (normally made on the 15th of the month, so a day early).
I previously posted some considerations I had in mind for this cycle, and received some helpful feedback in reply to that earlier post (thank you FletcherLynd!). I also posted a related question to 5i Research. (All the feedback and discussion is contained in the replies to my earlier post if you wish to follow along.)
So, in the end I did the following to take advantage of utility stocks for sale at a relative market discount and to address some major holes in our bond ladder:
- Sold Valener (TSX:VNR) and bought, with the proceeds and a small top-up to a full position, Algonquin Power (TSX:AQN) – this trade is intended to improve the quality of my utility holdings (I still like VNR but I like the total return prospects of AQN better)*
- Topped up Fortis (TSX:FTS) and Brookfield Renewables (TSX:BEP.UN) to bring them to full positions
- Journalled the new BEP.UN shares from a Canadian dollar account to a US dollar acount (BEP) to capture dividends in US dollars without incurring currency conversion rates (this will occur on settlement March 16) – I bought in a Canadian dollar account because I didn’t have enough US cash in the account to make the purchase directly in the US account
- Bought about 25% of my required bond purchases for the year, going short duration to fill holes in my investment grade ladder and in anticipation of higher rates later in the year (I will buy slightly longer duration bonds in June, September and December):
- FORD CREDIT CANADA LTD SR UNSECURED Maturity Jun 22 2022 Coupon 2.766 for a yield-to-maturity of 2.9%
- FAIRFAX FINL 6.4% 25MY21 for a yield-to-maturity of 2.84%
The net result is I’ve gone a bit overweight equities (I was slightly over-allocated already before trading). I sit at 49.5% versus 46% target, in part because equities, in spite of the correction last month, are still surging in my portfolio (tracking 17.3% on an annualized basis so far this year).
I’ll keep an eye on equity allocations as the year progresses and may trim a bit in technology if current trends persist. New cash should also help offset this imbalance a bit.
I will be doing my quarterly review at the end of the month and will post it along with my previous reviews here.
*Full disclosure – I’ve been a bit erratic with Valener. I bought it in September 2017 (just six months ago) as a long-term holding. At the time I wanted to buy Algonquin Power but thought it was too expensive. I have traded VNR for AQN opportunistically because of the sector rotation taking place in utilities that has made AQN’s price a more attractive entry point.
I have purposefully set a quarterly trading date for my buying and selling of securities to prevent over-trading and to provide time for reflection between trades.
Mid-March 2018 is my next trading window. What am I thinking?
I have accumulated a fair bit of cash/short-term bonds in our portfolio (almost 21% compared to our 9% target) that needs to be deployed. We are currently underweight bonds in our bond ladder (22% vs. 36% target), slightly overweight in stocks (48% vs. 46%) and about even in bullion at 9%.
I intend to purchase 1/4 of our underweight amount in bonds and will continue along the same path for the remaining three quarters. Yield to maturity in the retail, investment grade bond market, available via my discount brokers is now sitting at about 3.4% on five to six year maturities. So I will seek out positions of that nature. I also need to top up a bit in the three-year and four-year timeframes. So, as March 15 approaches, I will start filling those gaps.
The only other trade I am contemplating is to take advantage of the market’s current lack of interest in dividend paying stocks like utilities. I have been wanting to purchase Algonquin Power (TSX: AQN) for some time, and it now sits at a forward P/E of 16.47 and a growing dividend of 4.67%, rising steadily since 2009, which is pretty good for this “growthy” dividend payer.
FASTGraphs shows a total annual rate of return since January 2010 of 18.5%. YCharts shows it at a cumulative return of 370% in that same time period and StockRover shows a 102% cumulative five-year total return.
According to YCharts, it is 8.5% under value, and according to FASTGraphs it is 7.9% under value on a P/E basis. FASTGraphs has it at a 16% discount using historical price/operating cash flow measures. It is nearly 10% off its 52 week high.
So, even though this stock will push our equity allocation even a bit more over target, I believe it is a good addition to our portfolio, especially as we get a little closer to retirement. I may look to trim technology stocks again later this year to re-balance down a bit, since they seem to be making the fastest gains again so far this year (buy low, sell high is my thinking). As our savings, dividends and interest payments accumulate over the course of the year, the equity allocation will trend down slightly in relative terms (all things being equal).
I don’t really want to add another position (going to 34 equity holdings from 33), but I can’t see anything else to sell outright at the present time. And I do like AQN.TO, as does 5i Research (“one of our favourites”) who I follow. The latest commentary from 5i on the March 2 quarterly report suggests fundamentals are good (especially earnings). AQN’s recent acquisition seems to be working out fine as well.
I received an update from the Etobicoke Share Club that is getting up and running.
Meeting dates moving forward for the spring are on the 1st & 3rd Wednesday of the month at 6:30pm.
- March 21st
- April 4th
- April 18th
- May 2nd
- May 16th
- June 6th
- summers off
Meetings are held at Bloor & Islington, Centre Tower food court. 3300 Bloor St. W. Toronto.
Tell your friends and family in Etobicoke area (if you have them!)….
If you want more information please contact: etobicoke.investors [at] tutamail [dot] com